Your prototype works on the bench, but the connector housing won’t fit the enclosure, and the quote for the production run came back higher than planned. Both problems often trace back to one early choice: which parts are surface-mounted and which go through holes. Here is the short answer to SMT vs THT. Surface Mount Technology (SMT) is the default for most production boards because it is smaller, faster to automate and better at high frequencies. Through-Hole Technology (THT) is kept for connectors, heavy parts and joints that take mechanical force. Most real boards use both, and the rest of this guide covers how to decide the split, how each process works and how the joints are accepted.
1. SMD, SMT and THT: What Does Each Term Mean?
They describe different things. SMD (surface-mount device) is a part made to sit on pads on the board surface. SMT (surface-mount technology) is the assembly process that prints solder paste, places those parts and reflows them. THT (through-hole technology) is the process for parts whose leads pass through drilled, plated holes and are soldered on the far side.
- SMD vs SMT: one is the part, the other is the process. You buy SMDs; your assembler runs SMT.
- DIP (dual in-line package) is a through-hole package with two rows of leads, common on older ICs and sockets. “SMD vs DIP” is really a surface-mount vs through-hole package question.
- A board built only from SMDs is an SMT board. A board with both is a mixed-technology board.
Why does the difference matter before layout?
The choice sets your footprints, your soldering route and your cost. Surface-mount parts can go on both sides of the board, which roughly doubles the usable area. A through-hole part blocks space on both sides, because its leads come out the bottom. Changing a footprint after the first production run means a new board revision.
2. SMT vs THT at a Glance
SMT wins on density, speed, high-frequency behavior and unit cost. THT wins on mechanical strength, hand rework and probing. Use the table to see which column your product leans toward.
| Factor | SMT (Surface Mount) | THT (Through-Hole) |
|---|---|---|
| Mounting | On the surface | Through the board |
| Hole drilling | Minimal | Required for every part |
| Board density | High | Low |
| Placement speed | Extremely high | Moderate to low |
| Labor cost | Low | High |
| Vibration | Moderate | Excellent |
| Mechanical pull | Low | High |
| Signal speed | High | Moderate |
| Lead inductance | Minimal | Significant |
| Hand soldering | Difficult | Easy |
| Unit price of parts | Low | Higher |
| Availability | High (modern) | Limited (legacy) |
If more than a few rows point to THT for your board, read section 8 before you decide: you may need a mixed board rather than an all-THT one.
3. How Is an SMT Board Assembled?
In four automated steps: print, place, reflow, inspect. A stencil prints solder paste onto the pads, a pick-and-place machine sets each part, the board passes through a reflow oven, and the joints are checked. This is why SMT assembly scales so well with volume.
- Solder paste printing sets how much solder each joint gets, so stencil design drives yield.
- Pick-and-place machines place parts quickly and accurately from tape-and-reel feeders.
- Reflow melts the paste on every joint at once.
- AOI (automated optical inspection) is a standard step right after reflow.

Is SMD soldering difficult?
On a production line, no; by hand, it gets harder as parts get smaller. Larger passives can be hand-soldered with a fine tip, but fine-pitch ICs need hot air, and BGAs need a dedicated rework station because the joints are hidden under the package.
4. How Is a Through-Hole Board Soldered?
By wave soldering, selective soldering or hand soldering, after the leads are inserted. Wave soldering passes the whole underside over a wave of molten solder and suits boards with many THT parts. Selective soldering solders only the through-hole joints with a small nozzle, so nearby surface-mount parts are left alone. Hand soldering is used for prototypes and the odd late part in through-hole assembly.
What layout rules does selective soldering need?
Clearance and lead length, and they differ by machine type. A design paper from soldering-equipment maker SEHO Systems, published by IPC, gives these starting values:
| Rule | Single mini-wave nozzle | Multi-nozzle dip |
|---|---|---|
| Clearance around the joint | About 2 mm on three sides, about 5 mm on the side where the board leaves the wave | About 2–3 mm from parts that must not be soldered |
| Lead protrusion | About 1.0 mm (over 2.0 mm raises bridging risk) | More than 2.5 mm |
| Minimum pitch | More than 1.27 mm | More than 2.54 mm |
| Hole diameter | Pin diameter + 0.2–0.4 mm (lead-free may need + 0.5 mm) | Same |
The same paper notes that a part close to the joint should be shorter than its distance from the joint, so it does not hit the nozzle. If you cannot hold these clearances, tell your assembler before layout is frozen; it decides whether selective soldering is possible at all.
5. Which Holds Up Better Under Vibration, Shock and Heat?
THT holds up better where force goes into the joint; SMT holds up well under shock because the parts are light. The leads of a through-hole part are anchored through the board, while an SMT joint depends only on solder holding the part to a pad. Under high torque, an SMT pad can lift off the board.
- Connectors and switches that users push, pull or plug are the usual THT candidates.
- Heavy parts such as transformers are safer through-hole or with extra support.
- Low-mass SMT parts resist shock loads well.
How heavy is “too heavy” for solder alone?
NASA’s workmanship standard gives a clear line: parts weighing more than 7 g in total, or more than 3.5 g per lead, should be mechanically secured to the board with at least four evenly spaced bonds when nothing else supports them (NASA Workmanship Standards, 2002). It is a best-practice rule written for spaceflight hardware, so treat it as a conservative reference for industrial and automotive boards. A part above that line needs a through-hole anchor, adhesive staking or a bracket.
Does a through-hole joint need to be completely full of solder?
No. Testing of lead-free SAC305 through-hole joints found that pull strength tracked how much of the pin length was wetted, not the fill percentage, and that vibration caused the largest loss of strength while thermal cycling had little effect (Hewlett-Packard study, IPC APEX 2006). That is why acceptance rules (section 9) set a minimum fill rather than demanding 100%.
| Stress | SMT | THT |
|---|---|---|
| Thermal cycling | Good | Excellent |
| Shock resistance | High (low mass) | Moderate |
| Solder integrity | Process-dependent | Highly robust |
6. Which Performs Better at High Frequencies?
SMT. Short leads add less parasitic inductance, so fast signals keep their shape. Even a few millimeters of lead on a THT part can distort a high-speed edge, and long leads can act as small antennas that pick up noise.

- Surface-mount pads add less parasitic capacitance.
- Fewer through-holes leave the ground plane more continuous.
- Smaller current loops help RF designs.
For a board with high-speed data or a radio, keep the signal path surface-mount and treat any THT part on it as a layout risk.
7. Which Costs Less: Parts, Assembly or Rework?
SMT usually costs less per board in production; THT costs less to change during prototyping. Surface-mount parts are cheaper in volume and come on reels that feed straight into placement machines. Through-hole parts use more material, ship in tubes or bulk, and often need slower or manual insertion. Most new ICs are released in surface-mount packages first, and some have no through-hole version at all.
When is THT the cheaper choice?
During early R&D. You can swap a through-hole part with a soldering iron, clip a probe onto its leads and label it by hand, which can save days in quick-turn prototype assembly. SMT boards need test points designed into the layout and a hot-air station for rework.

| Cost driver | SMT | THT |
|---|---|---|
| Part price in volume | Low | Higher |
| Packaging | Reels (efficient) | Tubes/bulk (slow) |
| Assembly labor | Low | High |
| Rework on prototypes | Complex | Simple |
Key Takeaway: Prove the concept with THT if it helps, but plan test points and footprints for SMT before the first production quote.
8. When Does a Board Need Both, and How Is It Built?
When the logic needs density and the interface needs strength. The mixed technology PCB assembly process puts processors and memory on SMT and keeps connectors, large capacitors and heavy parts through-hole. The question is how the through-hole joints get soldered after reflow. There are three routes.
| Route | How it works | Fits when |
|---|---|---|
| Reflow + wave | SMT parts reflowed first; THT soldered in a wave pass. Bottom-side SMT parts must be glued and able to pass through the wave | Many THT parts on the board |
| Reflow + selective | THT joints soldered one area at a time with a small nozzle | A moderate number of THT parts, or sensitive SMT parts nearby |
| Pin-in-paste (through-hole reflow) | Paste is printed into the THT holes; the THT parts are reflowed together with the SMT parts | Only a few THT parts, all rated for reflow temperatures |
When can through-hole parts go through the reflow oven?
Only when the part is rated for it. In pin-in-paste, the THT part sees the full reflow profile. For lead-free reflow, IPC/JEDEC J-STD-020 sets peak package temperatures of 245–260°C depending on body thickness and volume, with up to 30 seconds within 5°C of peak (Texas Instruments, SNOA549D, 2016). Many connectors and electrolytic capacitors are designed only for wave soldering, so check the datasheet for a reflow rating before choosing this route.
How much paste does a pin-in-paste joint need?
More than the stencil usually prints. The required paste volume is the hole volume minus the pin volume plus the fillet volume, and because paste is roughly half flux by volume, only about 50% of the printed paste becomes solder (Indium Corporation). When the stencil cannot deliver enough, solder preforms add the missing volume.
9. How Are SMT and THT Joints Inspected and Accepted?
With different tools, because the joints fail differently. AOI checks visible SMT joints after reflow. X-ray is the only way to see hidden joints such as BGA balls. ICT and functional testing find electrical faults that look fine. Through-hole fillets can still be checked visually.
What hole fill do through-hole joints need?
For IPC-A-610 Class 2 and Class 3 products, most plated through-holes need at least 75% vertical solder fill; holes connected to power or ground planes are allowed 50%, because the planes pull heat away during soldering (IPC APEX 2006 paper). Class 1 sets no fill requirement. Confirm the IPC-A-610 revision named in your contract, since acceptance details change between revisions.
| Check | SMT joints | THT joints |
|---|---|---|
| Visible joints | AOI | Visual or AOI |
| Hidden joints | X-ray (BGA, QFN) | Not usually needed |
| Fill or wetting | Fillet shape | Vertical fill and pin wetting |
| Electrical faults | ICT, functional test | ICT, functional test |
10. How to Choose SMT or THT for Your Board
Start from SMT and justify every THT part. Each through-hole part should have a reason: mechanical force, mass above the support threshold in section 5, high-voltage isolation, or no surface-mount version.
| If the part… | Choose | Why |
|---|---|---|
| Carries high-speed signals | SMT | Low lead inductance |
| Is plugged, pulled or switched by users | THT | Mechanical anchor |
| Weighs more than 7 g, or 3.5 g per lead | THT, or SMT with staking | Solder alone may not hold it |
| Is one of only a few THT parts, reflow-rated | Pin-in-paste | Skips the wave or selective step |
| Is needed for a quick prototype change | THT | Easy rework |
| Ships in high volume | SMT | Automated speed and lower cost |
Decide the split while the schematic is still open, and review it with your assembler before layout is final.
Conclusion
Use SMT for density, automation, high-frequency performance and lower unit cost. Use THT for connectors, heavy parts and anything that takes mechanical force. On a mixed board, the real decisions are which parts earn a through-hole and which soldering route the THT parts take. We quote within 24 hours, with no minimum order quantity, and 2–4 layer FR-4 prototype boards are free. Send your Gerber files, BOM with manufacturer part numbers, target volume and operating environment, and contact us today for a review of the SMT/THT split before layout is frozen.
FAQ
Q1: What do SMD, SMT and THT stand for? SMD stands for surface-mount device, SMT for surface-mount technology and THT for through-hole technology. SMD is the part; SMT and THT are assembly processes.
Q2: What is the difference between SMD and DIP? DIP (dual in-line package) is a through-hole package whose two rows of leads go through the board. An SMD sits on pads on the surface, so it is smaller and suits automated assembly.
Q3: Is it more expensive to have a mixed technology board? Mixed assembly can add a soldering operation, tooling and inspection work. Compare quotations for the actual component mix, quantity and test scope; there is no fixed price premium that applies to every board.
Q4: Can I use SMT components for high-voltage power supplies? Review the component voltage ratings and the required creepage, clearance and insulation conditions for the product. The assembly method alone does not establish suitability for a high-voltage design.
Q5: How do I choose between wave soldering and selective soldering for THT? Wave soldering suits high-volume boards with many THT parts. Selective soldering suits mixed boards where the bottom-side SMT parts must not go through the wave.
Upload your files today · Free DFM check before production · Ship worldwide
Get your PCB prototypes in as fast as 24 hours. We handle FR4, Rogers, and hybrid boards, with standard builds up to 24 layers and higher layer counts subject to engineering review — free prototypes for 2–4 layer FR-4 boards, no minimum order.
Just upload your Gerber + BOM — we source every part, assemble, and inspect (AOI + X‑Ray) so you don't have to chase suppliers. PCB assembly typically takes 5–8 working days once all components are in stock. The confirmed delivery schedule is subject to your quotation.